Skip to main content

CoverCrushing · The Cover Lab · Pricing · FAQ · How testing works

Cover Testing · 7 min · September 24, 2026

How to Choose a Book Cover with Reader Votes

How to Choose a Book Cover with Reader Votes

A finished CoverCrushing test names a leading cover, a Crush Score, and a separate AI panel read. Here is how to turn that vote split into a publish, revise, or keep decision without treating the score as a sales forecast.

By The CoverCrush team · Editorial

A completed CoverCrushing test names a leading cover, gives a Crush Score and offers a separate AI panel read. Here's how to turn that vote split into a decision to publish, revise or keep, without treating the score as a sales forecast.

By The CoverCrush team · Editorial

Choosing a book cover with reader votes comes down to reading the comparison you actually paid for and then making a call. On CoverCrushing, the leading cover is the one with the most recorded votes in that test. The Crush Score describes how wide that lead was. The AI panel is a separate score. None of these outputs publishes the book for you, and none of them predicts sales. What follows is the decision order the report is built to support.

Begin only once the test is marked complete. A test stays open until its recorded vote count reaches that test’s target, and you get an email when it's marked complete. If you decide from a partial count, you're reading a test that hasn't finished. Wait for the target unless all you want is to confirm that votes have started coming in.

Read the vote split first

Open the results and see which cover has the most recorded votes. That cover is in the lead. An A/B test has two images. An A/B/C test has three or four. The leader is not “the prettiest cover” and not “the cover the AI liked most.” It's the cover voters picked more often in this test.

Write the split down as plain counts before you try to interpret it. If one cover has a clear majority of the recorded votes, you have a leader. If the counts sit close together, you have a near tie. The Crush Score is the site’s way of expressing that margin as a 0 to 100 figure. A wide margin produces a higher score than a near tie does. It doesn't measure how long anyone looked at a cover, and it isn't a forecast of sales or rank.

Sample size is the vote target on the test you launched. The new-author free A/B test targets 200 votes on two covers. A paid test uses whatever target was set for that test, and a larger target can take longer to reach than a smaller one. Don't compare your Crush Score with another author’s score from a different target, a different genre or a different pair of covers. The score only describes the files inside your own test.

Keep the AI panel in its own column

The AI panel scores each cover on a 12-criterion rubric from five perspectives: Genre Reader, Art Director, Retailer, New Reader, and Casual Browser. When the book is marked as part of a series, a Series Strategist takes the Casual Browser's place. Each perspective scores the criteria from 1 to 10, applies its own weights and returns a composite, a love-or-pass vote and a short comment. The panel composite combines those five scores.

Read this column after the vote split, not in place of it. The results view keeps AI panel output and reader votes apart on purpose. If readers pick Cover A and the panel composite prefers Cover B, you don't “average” them into some third cover. You have a disagreement between two clearly labeled inputs. The common cases look like this:

  • Readers and the panel choose the same cover. That's the simplest case for publishing, provided you're willing to ship that file.
  • Readers choose one cover by a wide margin and the panel is mixed. The vote still names the leader. Treat the panel notes as revision comments on typography, contrast, thumbnail legibility or genre signal, not as a veto over the count.
  • The vote is a near tie and the panel prefers one file. Read the vote as “either can lead” and use the panel to check whether one file is harder to read at a small size. You may still keep the cover you like better.
  • You don't like the leader. You don't have to use it. Some authors ship the winner, some brief a designer with the split and some keep the cover they preferred.

The CoverCrush Report pulls all of this together in one place. AI panel text is labeled as AI. Reader votes are counted on their own. The report names a leading cover and a score based on that vote split. Think of it as an aid while you decide, not a certificate.

Turn a clear lead into a decision

When one cover leads by a wide margin, you have three moves to choose from.

Publish the leader if the file is truly finished: the title is readable, the author name is readable and the genre you picked for the test matches the book you'll list. The test compared those images and nothing else. It didn't check your blurb, price or categories.

Revise the leader if the vote lead is clear but the panel, or your own eye, points to a fix that keeps the direction readers chose. Fixing contrast or type size on the winning direction is a different job from starting over. If you change the image so much that it becomes a new cover, it's a new test, not the old result.

Set the leader aside if you have a reason you can name: a rights problem, a series look you need to keep or a file that doesn't match the book. The report doesn't override that kind of constraint. Write down why you set it aside so the next test doesn't repeat a file you can't ship.

Turn a near tie into a decision

A near tie means the readers who saw these files didn't give you a strong leader. That usually points to one of two things. Either both covers work for this audience, so you can ship the one you prefer without pretending the data crowned it, or the covers are too alike for the test to see a difference. Look at the images side by side at thumbnail size. If you have to squint to tell them apart, the next test needs a real difference: another image, another type hierarchy or another genre cue. Testing the same two files again will just spend another test on the same split.

Don't invent a tie-break the product doesn't offer. No hidden sales model sits underneath the Crush Score. Price, blurb, category and the book itself still determine how a book sells. If you need another comparison, run another test with two covers that differ in a way you can describe. Another First Crush is $5 for your first paid test, then $12. Hard Crush is $29, and Crush It is $59. CrushPass ($19 per month) includes one A/B test credit per paid invoice, not unlimited tests. Pro Monthly ($29 per month) adds two A/B test credits every month you’re subscribed.

What not to do with the numbers

There's no reason to send the report to a retailer. CoverCrushing doesn't send results to Amazon, KDP, or IngramSpark, and a test doesn't change rank or sales. Don't treat a single-cover feedback score as a head-to-head win. Single Cover Feedback rates one cover. A preference between two covers exists only when both were in the same test.

Don't make the decision with your writing group and call it the same thing as this vote. The vote page is made up of people who picked genres and chose a cover, with a rate limit per IP. Friends who know you wrote the book are a different room. You can still ask them. Just keep their opinions out of the recorded vote count.

Don't hold out for a perfect score. The product doesn't define any Crush Score that “guarantees” a launch. A wide lead gives a clearer comparison than a tie, but it's still a comparison of the covers you uploaded.

When you're ready to run the comparison, start a cover test. If you don't have two finished files yet, read A/B testing versus a designer or a contest first.

Frequently asked questions

Q: How do I choose a book cover from reader votes? A: Wait until the test is marked complete. The leading cover is the one with the most recorded votes. The Crush Score describes how wide that lead was, from 0 to 100. Read the AI panel on its own. Then publish the leader, revise it or keep another cover. The report supports your decision. It isn't a sales forecast.

Q: What if the vote is close? A: A close split is a near tie. You can ship the cover you prefer, or you can test again with covers that differ in a way readers can see. The Crush Score comes out lower when the margin is narrow. It isn't hiding a second ranking.

Q: Should I follow the AI panel if it disagrees with the votes? A: Keep the two separate. Reader votes name the leader. The AI panel is a 12-criterion read from five perspectives, labeled as AI. Use the panel notes as revision comments, and don't average the panel into the vote count.

Q: Do I have to publish the winning cover? A: No. You can ship the winner, brief a designer with the split or keep the cover you preferred. Uploading the files doesn't transfer copyright, and the test doesn't change your Amazon rank.

Related reading

What CoverCrush is explains the vote, the panel and the prices. The FAQ is the short product reference, and it includes the refund rule for a test that doesn't reach its vote target within 72 hours.