From $5 Fiverr gigs to $2,000 custom commissions — here's exactly what you get at each price point, and how to decide what your book actually needs.
Before diving into pricing tiers, it's worth understanding what you're actually paying for. A book cover isn't just a piece of art — it's a marketing asset. It needs to signal the correct genre and sub-genre at thumbnail size (160×250 pixels on Amazon), compete visually with the top 20 bestsellers in your category, and convert browsers into buyers in under two seconds.
At this price point, you're looking at Canva templates, BookBrush, or the lowest tier of Fiverr. The output is usually a template with your title and name dropped in — sometimes with a stock photo that appears on dozens of other covers.
What you get: A cover that technically exists. It will have your title and name on it. It will probably look like a template.
What you don't get: Genre expertise, custom imagery, or any real design thinking. The cover will likely signal "self-published" to experienced readers in your genre.
When it makes sense: Never for a book you're seriously trying to sell. Possibly for a free lead magnet or a short story you're giving away.
This is the most dangerous price range, because it's where expectations and reality diverge most sharply. You'll find designers on Fiverr, 99designs, and various freelance marketplaces who charge in this range. Quality varies enormously.
What you might get: A competent designer who understands basic design principles and can produce something that looks professional at first glance.
What you might also get: Someone who doesn't read in your genre, doesn't understand sub-genre signals, and will produce something that looks nice but doesn't sell.
The problem: At this price point, you can't tell which you're getting until you've paid. Portfolio research is essential — look specifically for covers in your exact sub-genre.
This is where the market for serious indie authors lives. Designers in this range typically specialize in specific genres, understand the current market, and have portfolios full of covers that have actually sold books.
What you get: A designer who reads in your genre, understands sub-genre visual conventions, uses custom or heavily modified stock imagery, and delivers a cover that can compete with traditionally published books.
The hidden cost: Most designers in this range charge separately for the print cover wrap (back cover + spine), ebook formatting, and audiobook cover. Budget an additional $100–$200 for these if you need them.
At this level, you're typically working with designers who have a waiting list, specialize in a narrow genre, and have covers on USA Today or Amazon bestsellers. The difference between this tier and the $200–$600 tier is often less about technical skill and more about market positioning and access to premium custom illustration.
When it makes sense: If you're writing in a genre where covers are a major competitive differentiator (dark romance, epic fantasy, paranormal romance), and you have the marketing budget to support a serious launch.
At this price point, you're typically commissioning original artwork — a custom illustration or painting rather than a stock photo composite. This is standard in certain genres (epic fantasy, children's books) and unusual in others.
What you get: A cover that is genuinely unique, cannot be replicated by another author buying the same stock photo, and signals premium production value.
Most designers include 2–3 revision rounds in their quoted price. Additional revisions typically cost $50–$150 each. If you don't know what you want going in — if you can't articulate your genre, your comp titles, and your cover concept — you'll burn through revisions quickly.
The fix: Do your homework before you brief the designer. Study the top 20 covers in your sub-genre. Know your comp titles. Have a clear concept. The more specific your brief, the fewer revisions you'll need.
Here's a simple way to think about cover investment. If your book sells at $4.99 and you earn 70% royalties, you earn $3.49 per sale. A cover that converts 10% better on Amazon — which is a conservative estimate for a significant cover upgrade — generates an additional $349 per 1,000 browsers.
Over the life of a book with any real marketing behind it, the difference between a $200 cover and a $500 cover is often recovered within the first few hundred sales.
The smartest thing you can do at any price point is test your cover with real readers before you finalize it. A cover that looks great to you and your designer may not signal the right genre to your target readers — and you won't know until you test it.
CoverCrushing lets you put 2–4 cover variants in front of genre-matched readers and get data on purchase intent, genre clarity, and emotional response — before you've committed to a final design. At $12 per test, it's the cheapest insurance policy in publishing.
Share this article
We use cookies to improve your experience, analyze traffic, and show relevant ads. No header ads — ever. Privacy Policy